Which Cricut Should I Buy and Do I Need More Than One?

You have made the big decision to buy a Cricut. But which Cricut? I compiled a list of all the Cricut Cutting Machines and the pluses and minuses of each.  And do you need more than one?  This article will help you decide.

I have both the Maker and an Air machine.  I do not currently have the Joy but I have done a LOT of research about buying one.   And I have been using one type of Cricut or another for about 12 years.

Which Cricut is better for you?  That depends on the space you have, the money you are willing to spend and most importantly what you want to cut.


Which Cricut?  The Maker

The Maker is the latest version of the full sized cutter and definitely the most powerful.  While it doesn’t take the older Cricut cartridges, they can be loaded into Design Space either by buying the adapter or calling Cricut and having them loaded into your Design Space profile.  If you have the money and the space it is the best choice for you.  I would even say wait until you can afford it if you want to cut wood, fabric and most materials or if you want to engrave metals or glass.

  • Cuts the most materials – there is a list here
  • Uses much more pressure and therefore cuts through thicker materials
  • Added blades and tips – (Knife Blade, Engraving tip, Debossing Tip, Wavy Blade etc.)  See a complete list here and when to use which.
  • Interchangeable tips – the new tips are interchangeable using one housing which allows them to be cheaper.
  • Uses Design Space – Lets you design anywhere including on your phone and cut later
  • Has a USB Charging port and phone or tablet holder built in – Charge tablets or phones while you are working.
Which Cricut should I buy? - Air 2
Air 2

Which Cricut?  Air and Air 2

The Air and the Air 2 are basically the same machine, but the Air 2 is much faster.  I have the Air and notice some difference between it and my Maker.  But if you aren’t making things commercially, and don’t have to do things faster, there isn’t that big of a difference between the Air and Air 2.  

  • Limited in what it will cut – mainly vinyl, cardstock and bonded fabric.
  • Slower and uses less pressure than the Maker.
  • The newer tips and blades don’t work with the Air Series.
  • Only uses the scoring stylus for making score lines.  The single and double scoring wheels only work with the Maker.
Which Cricut? - The Joy

Which Cricut? The Joy

Before I start, I don’t own a Joy.  I have both the Air and the Maker. have plenty of room and don’t need one.  The Joy is portable and smaller.  It will cut longer vinyl without a mat because the vinyl designed for it comes with a “built in” mat.  You can buy a mat to go with it but the mat is only 4.5 inches wide, which limits the projects you can do with the Joy.

It has a much smaller footprint and is much more portable.  You can take it to your kitchen, plug it in and use it almost instantly.  If you don’t have a lot of room, this may be the machine for you!

I make mainly cards and the lack of a scoring tool is a deal breaker for me.  But if you want to do mainly vinyl this won’t bother you.

  • The mat is smaller (4.5 inches wide) limiting project size.
  • The Cricut Joy blades and pens are not interchangeable with the Air and Maker – you must buy Joy specific markers and blades.
  • It is very limited on the materials it will cut – basically only vinyl and cardstock.
  • Not USB Compatible only Bluetooth and doesn’t hard wire to the machine so the Bluetooth connection has to be stable.
  • Won’t do Print then Cut at all.  This limits the images you can cut from Design Space and uploaded files.
  • No Scoring Stylus or blades.  Scoring must be done after you cut with hand held scoring tools.

Older Machines

The Cake, Expression, Cricut Personal, Cricut Create and several others can be found on Ebay and other resale sites.  They all require cartridges that Cricut no longer sells.  You can get cartridges at the same resale sites but they cost just as much as they used to and any you buy are probably already registered to another user and can’t be uploaded to your Design Space Profile.  Cricut does not support these machines anymore.  They can design using illegal copies of Scan and Cut 2.  


If you find one at a garage sale for $5, they still aren’t worth it.

Do I need More Than One?

I have the Air and the Maker because I need to try projects for my webpage on both.  You really don’t need both unless you need to work faster (commercially make shirts or such).  The Joy being portable may appeal to you.  But if you already have the Air or the Maker and have the room to use them,  I don’t see a need for both.

Conclusion About Which Cricut Machine to Buy

If you are tight on cash, buy the Air 2 or the Joy.  If you have the cash buy the Maker.  As you get better and want to cut more materials, you will be grateful you did.  You can always buy one (Air or Joy) and then sell it to finance the Maker later, if you don’t have the funds right now.  Also Cricut has been having some sales lately, so keep your eyes open.  Or buy a used Maker machine on Ebay (that is how I got my 1st Maker), but you are taking a chance because it won’t be under warranty.

I hope this helps you decide which Cricut machine to buy.  Any questions or if you want my opinion on a deal, just email me at blog@crazycricutlady.com.  I will be glad to help.  And remember, once you get a Cricut, I have tutorials that will help.

Once you get a Cricut machine, consider buying an Access subscription.  It is well worth it.  Find out more about an Access subscription here.

2 thoughts on “Which Cricut Should I Buy and Do I Need More Than One?

  1. I had similar thoughts on the machines – until I got a Joy machine just for the heck of it. OMG – you have to get a JOY! it does the simple prefolded cards for a bunch of occasions so nicely and everyone loves the cards I’ve made for them. They are so dirt easy to do that it’s funny how people think you must have spent hours doing it. Nope, pick the design, pop the card insert onto the card mat and 10 minutes later, your done! The other great thing about the Joy is that it does labels for your kitchen sooooo easy too. That’s why you take it to your kitchen, not that it’s small, but so you can put matching labels on everything to give your kitchen that neat appearance with your own custom labels that all match.

    And yes, you are limited on the width, but not on the length for the most part, you when you want to do a large lettering or numbering project, you just have to think sideways. It’s great for one line at a time on most large signs and they are usually easier to assemble that way anyhow. It’s a lot of bang for your buck, and although they say you have to have the Joy pens, the ones for the maker and Explore machines will work with a small plastic adapter that you can buy cheaply from Etsy. It’s a lot cheaper than buying more pens just for the machine. Yes, it technically might void your warranty, but it does work beautifully. You can even get an adapter to use the foil tips on it.

    I think you should get one to try it out and make some awesome Joy card designs, as they are pretty simple once you get the hang of it. Who doesn’t love a custom card that looks like it took hours to make? I won’t tell your friends how easy it is….wink wink.

    1. I would love to get one but I just can’t justify the expense. At $150 dollars and having to buy all new extras like markers it just is not a viable option owning the maker and Air now.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.